Locavore concept violates core economic principles

  • Two agricultural economists believe that a key claim of local-food advocates — that local-food purchases enhance the local economy — violates the core economic principles taught in every introductory economics class.

From EconLib:

Oklahoma's government, like those of 45 other states, funds a farm-to-school program encouraging cafeterias to buy their food from local sources. U.S. Representative Chellie Pingree (D-Maine) wants to help; she recently introduced the Eat Local Foods Act (HR 5806) to assist schools in providing local foods in school lunches. From Michelle Obama's White House garden to grants from the U.S. Department of Agriculture's "Know Your Farmer, Know Your Food" initiative, an agenda has emerged to give local foods more prominence on our dinner plates. Interestingly, no agricultural economist has informed the public that a key claim of local-food advocates—that local-food purchases enhance the local economy—violates the core economic principles taught in every introductory economics class. Until now.

The Locavore's Dilemma: Why Pineapples Shouldn't Be Grown in North Dakota

Discuss this article 1

These two have been drinking the Walmart kool-aid. Because they are educators, they live in a different reality, making their living in a business unafected by large multi-national food companies.Small farmers can never compete on price with these giant firms. I guess the authors are suggesting these farmers get into another line of work. They suggest we should trust food produced by giant firms obssessed with buying and selling only at the lowest cost strictly to maximize return to institutional investors. Sure you can buy chicken mcnuggets cheaper and faster than a local small farm can raise, slaughter and sell you a fresh local chicken. Which is better for your body? Heck you and your family could then wolf it down in the car versus spending some time together cooking a chicken at home and wasting all that energy. How about some of that super cheap Chinese garlic, they would never adulturate it with something bad for the human body. Local farmers often grow organically , unlike the giants which utilize herbacides and pesticides and petrochemical fertilizers which leave residues on the resulting food we eat. Would the authors knowingly drink a glass of water containing these poisons and state they are harmless? Cheap food is full of hidden costs, costs that will have to be paid at some point either by ourselves or future generations. Eat local cleaner food now for a little more money or spend your cheap food savings on the rapidly escalating health care premiums, doctor vists, and a enjoy a shorter and less vibrant life span.

By Anonymous (not verified)  on Jan 6, 2011
Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your Western Farm Press ID
(optional)

Continuing Education Courses
New Course
The 2,000-member Weed Science Society of America’s (WSSA) Herbicide Resistance Action...
New Course

The course details six of the primary diseases affecting citrus: Huanglongbing (Citrus...

Get the latest info on almond insect pest management. California: 2 Hours "Other"
Farmer-to-Farmer Used Equipment