California agriculture targeted by heat illness bill

Calls to stop ‘Sue Your Employer’ heat bill
  • The California Assembly ignored already stringent heat illness rules on the books and passed another bill targeting agriculture alone. Assembly Bill 2346 aims to add impossible requirements to these rules along with punitive fines up to $200,000 for farmer violations.

Although heat illness-related incidents have decreased significantly over the past three years, the California Assembly ignored already stringent heat illness rules on the books and passed another bill targeting agriculture alone. Assembly Bill 2346 aims to add impossible requirements to these rules along with punitive fines up to $200,000 for farmer violations.

“Our workers are valuable to us and we fully support heat stress regulations that ensure farm worker safety and health. But this is an unnecessary bill that is just a thinly veiled ploy by a labor union trying to demonstrate its legitimacy,” said Tom Nassif, president and CEO of Western Growers.

Industry has conducted hundreds of training sessions around the state, reaching thousands of farmers, crew supervisors, managers and human resources directors.

In a recent press release, California Division of Occupational Safety and Health Chief Ellen Widess said, “We are pleased that years of continuous outreach, education and enforcement have resulted in fewer worker deaths and illnesses from exposure to heat.”

But despite the landmark improvements and already beefed-up heat illness regulations currently in effect, the California Assembly voted 41-27 to pass AB 2346.

“AB 2346 would warp the state’s heat illness regulations in ways that no farmer can implement,” said Assemblyman Bill Berryhill (R-Stockton) in debating the bill May 31 on the Assembly floor. “It simply attacks an entire industry. This, make no mistake, is an attack on farmers.”

“California’s family farmers are already working at many levels to make sure heat-illness related incidents are prevented. Farmers have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on portable shade units, ice machines and other tools to make sure farm workers have shade and cool water on the job,” Nassif said.

In 2005, California was the first state in the nation to adopt heat illness regulations. The regulation was strengthened in 2010 to include high heat provisions for five industries including agriculture.

AB 2346, also known as the “sue your employer” bill, establishes crippling fines for violations and contains “bounty hunter” provisions that encourage employees and legal aid groups to sue employers even though stiff penalties against violators already exist under the regulations. The law aims to create a private right of action, opening the door to abusive lawsuits by revenue-seeking legal aid groups.

Discuss this Article 4

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jun 7, 2012

Poorly thought out government again. Will it ever stop? Can they focus providing Californian’s with a balanced budget?

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jun 8, 2012

Water and a tarp to provide shade are crippling? Not as crippling as people dying. If these were your kids out working in those fields instead of migrant workers, you'd find a way to provide a means for people not to die for pay.

Michael Russell (not verified)
on Jun 9, 2012

This article is clear in its displeasure with the Assembly Bill 2346, but it does not say what is in the bill. It would be helpful to have at least a pragraph to discribe what is in the bill.

M. Russell

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jun 9, 2012

This is honestly such a ridiculous law! Farm labor contractors are doing such a great job to prevent these kind of accidents from happening! To some extent it's nearly impossible to provide water within ten feet, take a look at some of the fields, and how they are set up, not every ten feet would they be able to get the water in the field... If ranchers had to put a cut in their fields for every ten feet now your looking at money and a cycle going on, which would affect everyone in that case. This law is going to want to make alot of ranchers and contractors not even want to be a part of the ag business, running them out means that alot of workers would also be out of a job, once again making the states unemployment go up higher than what it is. Now we also have the food and safety issue to consider, how really is it suppose to work out together? And not only are their deaths in agriculture, why not go even all the way and go into all the industries that require their workers to be out in direct sun exposure? Seems pretty unfair. Alot of contractors are doing a great job shutting down their crews once it gets to certain degrees; this is just opening up an avenue for lawsuits that only lawyers and no one else will benefit from!! Or go after the contractors that do a horrible job following these or regulations, along with not paying the employees or shortening up their hours? And this is coming from a lady that will never, and has never been in the fields before, along with her coming from an are that doesn't go above the ninety degrees really?

Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your Western Farm Press ID
(optional)

Continuing Education Courses
This accredited CE course focuses on choosing the correct variety alfalfa based on a number of...
New Course
The 2,000-member Weed Science Society of America’s (WSSA) Herbicide Resistance Action...

The course details six of the primary diseases affecting citrus: Huanglongbing (Citrus...

Newsletter Signup