Farm Press Blog

Oregon GMO mystery wheat is a whodunit

  • Glyphosate-resistant wheat "mysteriously" shows up in eastern Oregon field; It was obviously planted there.

The discovery of unapproved Rounup Ready soft white wheat in eastern Oregon has been called a “mystery.”

It is no mystery. Someone planted it.

The questions are who and where did the seed come from?

Guarantee it was not dropped from the sky by Lucifer masquerading as Monsanto.

The last year Monsanto tested GMO wheat in Oregon was 2001 — 12 years ago. Monsanto did not have any test sites near the mystery find. Wheat seed cannot lay dormant in the soil for more than a decade and still germinate. It is highly unlikely that a bag of conventional wheat seed was inadvertently contaminated by RR wheat. Besides, wherever experimental seed is processed, government regulations and the seed companies themselves demand thorough machinery clean-out procedures.

Did the yet unidentified growers somehow get hold of the unregulated seed, plant it deliberately and then cry wolf to appease the anti-GMO radicals? Until the grower is identified and tells his side of the story, we can only speculate. It is curious why and when he sprayed Roundup on this mysterious wheat, which is how he reportedly discovered the rogue plants. Why would anyone spray a wheat field with glyphosate in the first place?

It is interesting that this comtaminated wheat find was in eastern Oregon. One of the plantiffs in the protracted and expensive anti-RR alfalfa lawsuit operates a seed plant in eastern Oregon. Millions were spent challenging the planting of RR alfalfa to no avail. Sore loser? Sabatoge. Monsanto has not ruled that out. I wouldn’t either.

While this so-called GMO disaster is a bit suspicious at first blush, it is no joke to Oregon wheat farmers. The U.S.exported $8.1 billion worth of wheat in 2012  — nearly half of the total $17.9 billion U.S. wheat crop.

Following the USDA’s confirmation of GMO contamination, Japan immediately canceled a 25,000-ton import of soft white wheat, and both South Korea and Europe announced more stringent testing of American wheat shipments. Ninety percent of Oregon’s soft white wheat is exported to Asia.

Monsanto withdrew its application to develop the variety in 2004, because export markets didn't want GM wheat. There was not enough profit potential in RR wheat for Monsanto to fight GMO embargos, so it dropped the program. The irony of this GMO controversy is that Oregon wheat growers plant a herbicide resistant wheat. It’s resistant to imazamox, not glyphosate. Oregon wheat growers are quick to point out that the Clearfield herbicide-resistant wheat variety was not developed using DNA insertion. Apparently, however, it was bred traditionally using DNA marker technology, which was a biotechnology development. This technology allows breeders to more quickly identify desirable genes. It significantly reduces the time it takes to develop a new wheat variety. In reality, Clearfield wheat is a product of biotechnology.

Why is one plant development method accepted and another isn't? "In countries where your belly button is chewing on your backbone, it's probably not an issue," Darren Padget, a fifth-generation eastern Oregon wheat grower was quoted in The Oregonian newspaper.

USDA is investigating. I suspect researchers will be able to trace the DNA in the glyphosate wheat to its origin. It will be a trail to the truth.


More from Western Farm Press

Farmland values still climbing, but pace slows

What a grocery store without honey bees looks like

EPA’s Pinocchio nose grows with farmer privacy scandal

5 lessons from the Honeygate scandal

Buyers out in force for 2013 coastal varieties

Wine grape drone flying over California vineyards

Discuss this Blog Entry 5

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jun 24, 2013

Is it possible that the wheat could have been pollinated by RR wheat 12 years ago and the genetics were passed on as the farmer saved the seed? It is less likely that someone planted it for sabotage than Monsanto dropped it from the sky... how could they plant several plants in an entire field? Ludicrous.

AgLander (not verified)
on Jun 24, 2013

It should be investigated like a crime caper.......

1) Who had a motive? (The anti-GMO food anarchists who want to destroy Monsanto using any means or methods.)

2) Follow the money trail. (Someone looking for an easy payday by staging an event for the purpose of a lawsuit.)

You are likely to find the answer within one or both of those groups.

A healthy prison term is warranted once those responsible are exposed.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jun 24, 2013

"It is curious why and when he sprayed Roundup on this mysterious wheat, which is how he reportedly discovered the rogue plants. Why would anyone spray a wheat field with glyphosate in the first place?"
It is a common practice in eastern Oregon to leave wheat fields fallow every other year for moisture to build up in the soil, which is why they're sprayed with glyphosate. Seems like a farm publication should be aware of this.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jun 24, 2013

However the wheat got into the field, it is possible that the grower would spray glyphosate during the fallow period for weed control to prevent the spread of weeds and conserve soil moisture for the next wheat crop.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jun 25, 2013

Road apples!
IF someone(s) were trying to 'do in' Monsanto, they would attempt it in a much more public way. They would not wander into the middle of nowhere to 'salt' a remote field with a few hundred seeds from over a decade ago.

What this episode does demonstrate, however, is how hazardous GM seed is to America's Export Market and how little knowledge of and control over Mother Nature we mortals have.

What good does it do to have more productive seed, if 50% of the World Market considers it poisonous and will not buy it?

Plus Monsanto's GM corn (Bt) already failed last Season in the IL, IA, MN, WI region, and Monsanto has no "Plan B". Mother Nature 2 - Monsanto 0.

"Magic Bullets" are ephemeral.

Post new comment
or register to use your Western Farm Press ID
What's Farm Press Blog?

The Farm Press Daily Blog

Connect With Us

Blog Archive
Continuing Education Courses
The purpose of this course is to give you a review of many aspects of spray drift – from...
Potassium nitrate has a positive effect in controlling plant pests and diseases when applied...
American agriculture exports 20 to 30 percent of its production annually. For specific...

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×