Farm Press Blog

Golden rice battle only just beginning

RSS
  • Golden rice is a lightning rod issue, with anti-GMO campaigners putting up fierce resistance to a crop that could save the lives of millions of children.

Rice is king — the food staple of the world. It is also a political lightning rod and the newest battleground in the GM crop war.

Golden rice, created in the late 1990s, offers a lifeline to millions of children that die each decade from vitamin A deficiency. In addition, golden rice may keep millions of children from going blind in the same time frame.

In 1999, scientists in Europe took rice DNA and inserted beta-carotene genes — vital to the human body in producing vitamin A. After several more years of trials, research and varieties, a single bowl of golden rice can now provide 60 percent of needed vitamin A intake for children.

Such promise should have paved a golden rice path toward the sustenance of millions of vitamin-deprived children. Instead, stopping golden rice has become a crusade for anti-GMO campaigners who have hurled a barrage of false — but headline grabbing — claims against golden rice.

Greenpeace claims golden rice holds minimal nutritional value, and would require consumption of several kilograms to get vitamin A benefits. Robin Mckie, writing in the Guardian, exposed the emptiness of Greenpeace’s position: “Two studies, both published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, demolished this claim. The first, in 2009, was based on a group of healthy adult volunteers in the US and showed that golden rice's beta-carotene was easily taken up into the bloodstream. The second trial was carried out by American and Chinese researchers and published last year. It was carried out on Chinese children, aged between six and eight, and showed that a bowl of cooked golden rice, between 100g and 150g, could provide 60% of the recommended intake of vitamin A for young people. The study also revealed that golden rice is better than spinach at providing vitamin A.”

 

Want access to the very latest in agriculture news each day? Sign up up for the Western Farm Press Daily e-mail newsletter.

 

The Chinese trial brought a hysterical response from Greenpeace: “24 children used as guinea pigs in genetically engineered "Golden Rice" trial.”

Greenpeace and the anti-GMO campaigners would have Asia and African children rely on supplements to remedy vitamin A deficiency. Supplements are a weak solution when compared with the sustainability of golden rice — particularly when millions of lives hang in the balance. Farmers should have the choice to plant and countries should have the choice to distribute golden rice, but that still may be several years away.  From an NPR report: “Later this year, the network of golden rice researchers will apply for approval in the Philippines. After that, they'll do the same in Bangladesh … This will be the final test of that 30-year-old brainstorm — the idea that genetically altered rice actually could be a cheap, self-multiplying source of this vital nutrient.”

Greenpeace is watching events in the Philippines with a close eye and will be quick to tag Filipino children as “guinea pigs.” But as Bjorn Lomborg writes on Slate.com, “The 4.4 million Filipino kids with vitamin A deficiency might not mind so much.”

Twitter: @CBennett71

More from Western Farm Press

Death, liberty, Cheetos, and the American way

Bowman v. Monsanto could open GM Pandora’s box

Counterfeit food robs Americans of $10 billion each year

Discuss this Blog Entry 1

Anonymous (not verified)
on Mar 27, 2013

Vitamin deficiency is no joke, nor is any form of malnutrition, but you don't get a healthy diet by frankensteining foods... you get it by a more diverse diet. The world is not in need of a staple grain like rice that has been augmented enough times to give us a life-sustaining dog food. We need healthy diverse diets to bring us our vitamins... not supplements or engineered foods. If we want beta-carotenes... eat carrots... vitamin A, eat spinach and other foods, i'm not a nutritionist... but one food for all and all the time, is a BAD IDEA.

Post new comment
or to use your Western Farm Press ID
What's Farm Press Blog?

The Farm Press Daily Blog

Connect With Us

Blog Archive
Continuing Education Courses
New Course
California is becoming the first state in the nation to invoke regulations to reduce Volatile...
New Course
Ant control is an important element of harvesting a high quality almond crop. It starts with...
This accredited CE course focuses on choosing the correct variety alfalfa based on a number of...

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×