Farm Press Blog

Conventional grower inherits puncturevine, mites from organic grower

  • Conventional growers spends more because of organic neighbor. Regulations protect organic grower, but penalize conventional grower.

It’s worthy to be a good neighbor, whether you live in a subdivision, condo, apartment or farm for a living.

Hopefully, it is reciprocal.

That has not been the case for a central San Joaquin Valley raisin producer who has not only been a bad neighbor, but one who is backed by the law, specifically, regulations for organic farming.

Organic is a big deal these days ... at least in the minds of some consumers who believe organic is better and pesticide-free. It is neither. However, consumers are willing to pay more for organic, and growers who can profit from that are rightfully taking advantage.

If growers want to play in the philosophical organic market, they must follow organic production laws. Organic producers can only use crop protection products approved for organic production. Those rules also impact conventional growers who neighbor organic producers.

Inadvertent spray drift of a non-organically approved crop protection product is the most obvious threat to a neighbor’s organic certification. If residue from a non-organically approved product is detected on the crop, it is devastating.

Growers never purposely drift chemical onto neighboring crops, but it happens. Usually it is not draconian. If it is in conventional agriculture and economic damage is proven, insurance or an agreement to pay restitution between the violator and the damaged grower takes care of it.

But what about the actions or inactions of an organic grower that impacts a conventional grower?

That’s what is happening with a valley raisin grower who is inheriting puncturevine and spider mites from an organic grower who is not taking care of business. (He asked that we not use his name.)


Want access to the very latest in agriculture news each day? Sign up for the Western Farm Press Daily e-mail newsletter.


The grower talked to the organic farmer’s foreman to no avail. He went to his county ag commissioner who told him there were no regulations requiring organic growers to confine unwanted pests to organic fields.

Mites are costly to control, especially if they coming from a neighbor’s field. Puncturevines are more onerous because hand pickers are often on their hands and knees gathering grapes to dry on the trays and puncture vines are nasty. If there are enough of them in a vineyard, the harvest crew could walk off the job. No one would blame them.

The organic grower tries to control the noxious weed with burn down organic cinnamon/clove oil spray herbicide. Might as well just toss hot water on puncturevine. They come back. They wouldn’t with a benign translocating herbicide.

When housing developers put in subdivisions, they must to pay impact fees for roads, fire, police, sewer and the like. Perhaps there needs to be an impact fees for organic growers. And maybe some additional regulations like a 100-foot setback from the edge of a road. That would provide a conventional grower with a buffer against inadvertent drift.

It’s not neighborly to restrict conventional farmers and cater to organic growers. It is conventional farming that is feeding the world. Organic never will.


More from Western Farm Press:

Farmer guilty of defending family with gun

Raisin grower turns attention to mites

California cotton farm gives no-till a try

Discuss this Blog Entry 5

john lord (not verified)
on Aug 3, 2013

Now that organics is in the main stream it is not having it all its own way any more. The shrill criticisms thrown at conventional farming by the organic movement means it can hardly complain when some of it comes back in their direction.

B.Real (not verified)
on Aug 8, 2013

Well what about all the impacts of conventional farming on ecosystems? Nitrate pollution of groundwater, bee decline, bird culls, farm worker deaths and diseases....? Organic growers already have to pay to become certified- but conventional growers can spray away without any retribution and little oversight. Farming is not about controlling nature, its about working with it. (Oh, and BTW- the United Nations reported that small scale organic farming is THE ONLY WAY that we can sustainably feed the world.)

Tom Dowd (not verified)
on Sep 11, 2013

What the hell do you mean "with little oversight"? It's quite apparent you've never participated in an ag chem application or you would never utter those words!

on Sep 11, 2013

What the hell are you talking about "without any retribution and little oversight"? Go try and buy a ag chem without being certified and obtaining a permit or a grower' ID from the local Ag Commissioner. Then try doing the application without being interrupted by a member of the Ag Comm staff. AND try doing one without completing the required paperwork. You obviously have never been involved in farming or you wouldn't be saying these things. Do a little research before you continue to embarrass yourself.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Aug 9, 2013

An article , on this site July 11, 2013 , stated that mites were a problem this season throughout the grape growing area of California . Why blame that on the organic farmer ?

Post new comment
or register to use your Western Farm Press ID
What's Farm Press Blog?

The Farm Press Daily Blog

Connect With Us

Blog Archive
Continuing Education Courses
Sponsored by Monsanto, this accredited Weed Resistance Management CEU gives an overview of...
New Course
The Federal Organic Foods Production Act set standards for both growers and consumers, and the...
New Course
Mites are small arthropods in the class Arachnida and the subclass Acari. Although they are...

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×